Wrongness About ADHD? Who’s Wrong?— ADD Tip O the Day 688

All Wrong

We’re thinking all wrong about ADHD,  Dr. Christakis, “a leading pediatrician,” says.

“The current thinking in the field is that attentional capacity and skills do occur on a    continuum or spectrum.” He also says that in general, pediatrics is evolving toward the idea of proactively supporting attentional functioning in everyone.”

I think he’s going on theory and ignoring the data, and I think he’s wrong, but there may a grain of truth.  Being “a leading pediatrician” doesn’t mean you can’t be  wrong.  Anybody remember Dr. Linus Pauling?

But

But Dr. Mahone seems to agree. but then says, “It doesn’t mean that diagnoses and medication aren’t helpful and appropriate in severe cases of ADHD.” And, he says, “There is strong, and growing, evidence of specific brain abnormalities associated with severe ADHD symptoms, which would lend support to the concept of ADHD as a brain disease.”

It is a little confusing.

Dimitri Christakis is a professor of pediatrics at the University of Washington and the director of the Center for Child Health, Behavior and Development at Children’s Hospital in Seattle.   The link:   All Wrong

Mark Mahone is a pediatric neuropsychologist at the Kennedy Krieger Institute for children with special needs.

There’s lot more. You need to read the article.  All Wrong

Is it a bell shaped curve or is there a big blip off to the left?  See what I mean?

doug

Note:

I was just informed that this post is not clear.  Basically, Dr. Christakis is saying that ADHD doesn’t really exist.  I disagree.  Dr. Mahone first agrees with Dr. Christakis but then says ADHD does exist.  If you define ADHD as a set of symptoms, and then find that there are differences in the brains of people with those symptoms compared to those without, then it exists, in my and Dr. Mahone’s opinions.

Dr. Christakis says it’s just that some normal people have lower attention than others, some have higher, and most are in the middle.  It’s a bell shaped curve, like height, for example. But I suggest that people who are midgets, caused by abnormal genes, are off the height curve, and  we ADDers are off the attention curve.  We have less attention than the normal people with low attention. That’s why we are the blip beyond the lower end of the curve, off the bell shaped curve, not just normal and at the low end.

I hope that clarifies.  Now technically, it’s maybe not that we have low attention, it’s more that we have poor control of our attention, but that’s a whole nother argument.

ADD,ADHD,attention deficit,controversy,controversy,disorder,normal,abnormal,adult add,adult adhd,@dougmkpdp,@addstrategies,#add,#ADHD

Dr. C’s theory

ADD,ADHD,attention deficit,controversy,controversy,disorder,normal,abnormal,adult add,adult adhd,@dougmkpdp,@addstrategies,#add,#ADHD

doug’s theory

Advertisements

About doug with ADHD

I am a psychiatric physician. I learned I have ADHD at age 64, and then wrote two ADHD books for adults, focusing on strategies for making your life better. Your Life Can Be Better; strategies for adults with ADD/ADHD available at amazon.com, or smashwords.com (for e books) Living Daily With Adult ADD or ADHD: 365 Tips O the Day ( e-book). This is one tip at a time, one page at a time, at your own pace. It's meant to last a year. As a child, I was a bully. Then there was a transformation. Now I am committed to helping people instead abusing them. The Bully was published in January, 2016. It's in print or e book, on Amazon.
This entry was posted in add, controversies, controversy, educate yourself, science and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Wrongness About ADHD? Who’s Wrong?— ADD Tip O the Day 688

  1. Gina Pera says:

    When I see a headline like that (what the heck is a “top pediatrician” anyway), I know that it’s a puff piece with an agenda—and I don’t bother reading. 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Anonymous says:

    I’ve read this, re-read and followed all the links. I’ve mulled it over, re-read it, etc. You’re right, Doug, it’s quite a lot, and quite confusing at that. On one hand, they advocate that we don’t medicate kids as quickly as we do. On the other hand, they complain about kids not being dealt with once they’re bellow a certain point (i.e. only 5/9 Symtoms instead of 6/9). It doesn’t make much sense to me because we do need to draw a line somewhere. And because if we start giving all the kids a special treatment to improve their “Focus curve” to the max, wouldn’t the ADD/ADHD kids start falling short too? I’m no expert, but I’m inclined to go with your view, Doug. I think in the lower end of the bell curve, there is another bell curve for ADD/ADHD people.

    Liked by 1 person

    • The Bully says:

      anon – good for you, you really did your home work. If we’re right, I think we need to only medicate the kids who are off the curve, and i think they (we) are clearly different from those who are just at the low end. And i think its not just a question of of number of symptoms on a check list, it’s “Wow, this kid really has ADHD and needs help, now!”
      I think the research shows that medication will not help the low end kids, only the ones off the chart, with our brains that are different.
      and if they’re not too bad, i think the idea of trying behavioral approaches before meds makes some sense, but i also suspect they won’t be very effective, at least not without the meds first.
      the meds aren’t the anwer, but they help, and they make it easier to learn and use the strategies and the counseling and coaching that needs to be available.
      thank you for contributing
      doug

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s